Skip to main content
FMB Logo Header Desktop
Scroll To Top


Debt consolidation involves combining multiple debts and streamlining payments to a single creditor, often with the benefit of lowering interest rates. It can accelerate debt payoff and save you money, lifting financial pressures.

This article will provide various ways to consolidate debt and considerations to make before consolidating.

Reach Out Today


Best debt consolidation options

Consider consolidating multiple debts into one to speed up your debt repayments and potentially save money. Methods include balance transfers, consolidation loans, and leveraging home equity.

1. Debt consolidation loan

Debt consolidation loans are tailored to assist in repaying a large sum of debt at once. Ideal for those struggling with a high interest rate or juggling multiple loans with various lenders, a debt consolidation loan allows you to move your debts with other lenders to one chosen lender, so you only have one lender to pay simple monthly repayments to.

If you get a debt consolidation loan that has shorter repayment periods and lower overall interest compared to existing debts, it can be a great way to lower your monthly repayments.

This method of debt consolidation requires good credit, and you would need to make monthly payments and origination fees to the lender.

Try our consolidation calculator


2. Balance transfer credit card

You can consolidate your debt using a balance transfer credit card with a 0% APR introductory period for balance transfers. This method can streamline smaller debts and save on interest, but careful management is key to maximizing its effectiveness.

Simply select a card based on credit limit and transfer fees, transfer your balances carefully, and enjoy interest savings during the promotional period.

Using a credit card balance transfer makes it easier to manage debts. However, you should be mindful of the limited promotional period and potential transfer fees. If you use a credit card to consolidate debt, plan to pay off balances before the promotional period ends to avoid higher interest rates and fees.


3. Tapping into home equity

This debt consolidation option is suitable for those with substantial home equity seeking higher loan amounts. A home equity loan allows homeowners to leverage their home equity for a lower-interest loan, offering secured financing at potentially lower rates than credit cards.

Home equity borrowers should be aware of potential costs like closing fees and the risk of foreclosure if loan payments are not maintained. These costs can be estimated using tools like a home equity calculator.

Discover Home Equity Loans


4. Debt management plan (DMP)

A debt management plan, or a DMP, provides a structured approach to consolidating debts, helping people repay debts affordably. These loans are best suited to those struggling with the original repayment amounts.

A DMP can be facilitated by a non-profit credit counseling agency, but you may encounter fees for the service and the plan often involves closing credit accounts and restrictions on new credit use.

Despite this debt consolidation process involving budgeting and negotiating for lower interest rates and fees, a debt management plan is a viable option for individuals in deep debt seeking to regain financial stability.


5. Use a cash-out auto refinance

Cash-out auto refinance typically lets you borrow against your home or car's equity, providing cash for expenses such as consolidating your debt. This process involves refinancing your existing auto loan for a higher amount than what you owe, with the difference given to you in cash.

A cash-out refinance can potentially secure a better interest rate on your auto loan and access to cash for paying off high-interest debt. This approach can also lower your overall interest costs and simplify payments into a single installment.

However, this debt consolidation method usually increases your total debt amount and puts your home or vehicle at risk of repossession if payments aren't maintained. Consider this option thoughtfully, especially if you want to lower your credit utilization ratio and potentially improve your credit score over time.


6. Borrowing from retirement accounts

If you have an employer-sponsored retirement savings plan such as a 401(k), you could borrow up to half its value (capped at $50,000) from this to consolidate your debts. You can borrow from your retirement account for up to five years, and this method usually offers lower interest rates than unsecured loans and doesn't affect your credit score.

However, borrowing from your 401(k) involves jeopardizing your retirement fund and incurs penalties if not repaid. This is a high-risk strategy with potential tax implications and missed investment growth.

Calculate your retirement savings


7. Mortgage debt consolidation

Consolidating debt into a mortgage involves borrowing against your property to pay off unsecured debts such as credit cards or loans.

While it can reduce monthly payments and offer lower interest rates, extending repayment terms may increase the total interest paid and pose the risk of home repossession if payments are missed.


8. Get a personal loan

A personal loan is an installment loan disbursed in full upfront, repaid through periodic installments over a set term, typically without prepayment penalties. Getting a personal loan to consolidate debts involves obtaining an unsecured loan with a fixed interest rate, typically for borrowers with good credit.

Beyond debt consolidation, these loans fund major expenses like medical bills, car repairs, weddings, or vacations, with some restrictions on usage. With a personal loan, you can immediately pay off debt and establish a structured repayment plan.

Personal loans often offer lower interest rates than credit cards, making them suitable for extended debt repayment. However, borrowers may encounter upfront costs like loan origination fees and must meet eligibility criteria.

While consolidating simplifies payments and may improve credit scores with timely payments, missed payments can increase overall costs and jeopardize financial stability. Before committing, it's essential to calculate potential savings and assess suitability based on individual financial circumstances.


Should I consolidate my debt?

Debt consolidation can be advantageous if you're juggling multiple high-interest debts and seeking simplified payments. It's most effective for credit card debts, auto loans, medical expenses, personal loans, and student loans.

Debt consolidation offers several benefits, including streamlining and simplifying your finances by consolidating payments into one, reducing payment complexity, potentially accelerating debt payoff, qualifying you for lower interest rates, and boosting your credit score with timely payments.

Consider exploring different consolidation options aligned with your financial goals, aiming for a shorter repayment period and lower interest rates than your current debts to maximize savings and financial outcomes.

Use a calculator to assess how consolidation impacts your monthly payments and interest savings, taking into account your credit score and loan terms for overall benefit. Applicants should also consider that debt consolidation can lead to higher interest rates, extended repayment periods, and upfront costs. Additionally, late or missed payments can incur fees, and the calculator may not address underlying financial issues effectively.

Determining if debt consolidation is a good idea depends on your specific financial situation and objectives.

Talk to an expert


When to avoid debt consolidation

Avoid debt consolidation if you lack the income to comfortably cover the new consolidated monthly payment. Additionally, it's advisable to avoid consolidating your debt if you have poor credit, minimal debt, or struggle with budgeting. Depending on the debt consolidation method, applicants should avoid applying for loans or credit cards if the interest rate is high.

Does consolidating debt help your credit score?

Consolidating debt can initially lower your credit score due to a hard credit inquiry, typically by five points or less.

However, closing old credit accounts after consolidation can lower the average age of your accounts, which can negatively impact your credit score.

In the long term, making timely payments after a debt consolidation can improve your credit score. This does vary based on your consolidation method and payment history.


How to consolidate debt into one payment

  1. Evaluate your options. Decide on the best consolidation method for you, such as a balance transfer, debt consolidation loan, home equity loan, or retirement account loan. Consider the impact on your credit score and overall financial situation.
  2. Research and apply. Use a reputable loan consolidation calculator to assess your options. Apply for a loan online, answering a few questions to determine your eligibility and see potential offers.
  3. Compare offers. Review loan offers from various lenders, comparing important factors like APR and monthly payments. Choose the best option based on your needs and financial goals.
  4. Lock in your rate. Once you've chosen a lender, complete the application process on their website. Provide necessary financial documents for verification.

Inquire about a debt consolidation loan with First Merchants today!

If you have a significant amount of debt and a solid plan for financial improvement, along with a good credit score and stable cash flow, it might be the right time to explore your debt consolidation options.

Use our loan consolidation calculator to explore different APRs and loan terms and how they could affect your monthly payment and how long it will take to pay down debt without affecting your credit score. This way you will have an idea of what is possible before you apply.

At First Merchants, our bankers are here to help. We'll listen carefully, and help you explore your debt consolidation loan options. Make an appointment to meet with an attentive First Merchants banker or apply online now.

Apply for Debt Consolidation Loan