Chris Nolley

Account Executive

Chris has worked in the insurance industry since 1993. His first experience brought a wealth of knowledge on the Life side of the industry, as that was his primary focus for the first two years. Chris added Personal lines property and casualty insurance to his experience, including management of a high-volume personal lines agency in the Indianapolis market.

The knowledge gain through these experiences led Chris to open Nolley Insurance Services Inc. in 1997. Nolley Insurance Services Inc. was a full lines independent insurance agency that wrote all lines of insurance, including the addition of business insurance. Chris owned and operated this successful agency for more than 10 years before selling the agency.

Chris chose to join First Merchants Insurance Group to enhance his ability to serve his clients through the additional markets and added expertise of a much larger agency. Chris is currently furthering his insurance education with courses to obtain a Certified Insurance Counselor Designation.

Outside of insurance, Chris has been very active in his community. He was a founding member of Mainstreet Shelbyville Inc. and the Strand Theatre of Shelbyville Inc. His work with the Strand Theatre project earned him the "Citizen of the Year" award in 2007 from the Shelby County Chamber of Commerce. He currently serves on the executive board of the Strand Theatre and as an Ambassador for the Shelby County Chamber of Commerce.

Call Chris at 317.883.8811 or email him at


Funds are not insured by the FDIC, and are not deposits of, or guaranteed by, First Merchants Bank N.A. or any of its affiliates. Funds are subject to investment risk if the insurance has a cash value, including possible loss of the principal amount invested. Insurance products are made available through First Merchants Insurance Services, Inc., a licensed insurance agency affiliate of First Merchants Bank, N.A. Insurance products are underwritten by, and are the obligations of, the insurance companies that issue the insurance policies; these insurance companies are not affiliated with First Merchants Bank, N.A.

Chris Nolley
Account Executive

Business, auto, home, life, group health insurance 


Office: 317.883.8811
Cell: 317.512.7712
Fax: 317.883.8812

648 Treybourne Drive
Greenwood, IN 46176