First Merchants
Insurance Services

First Merchants Insurance Services (FMIS) provides superior performance and focused insurance solutions to businesses and individuals. Our capabilities extend from insuring a wide range of property and casualty risks to the development, administration and support of flexible, cost-conscious employee benefit programs. As an independent agency, we work solely as advocates for our clients, representing dozens of A rated insurance companies to ensure the best combination of coverage and price.  We are distinguished by our diverse risk management expertise and our long-standing reputation as creative problem-solvers.

We are proud to be a part of the First Merchants Corporation family, an alliance which accomplishes the following:

  • Greater financial resources
  • Expanded service capabilities
  • Exceptional stability
  • Broader market access
  • Direct ties to a respected financial institution
  • Seamless integration with mutual fund groups and money managers

 Our dedication to maintaining the highest standards for ethics and professionalism has earned us coveted standing as one of our region's premier full-spectrum independent agencies, along with Preferred and Leadership distinction with top-rated carriers. 

Solutions For Success

Maintaining your competitive edge is the key to success regardless of market conditions. Businesses struggle to protect both their benefits programs and their bottom line. Homeowners and families struggle to secure their assets and their financial futures.  Helping you triumph over these and other challenges is both our passion and our purpose.  We're constantly exploring new ways to protect your business interests, safeguard your employee benefits program and shield your personal assets. Count on FMIG for the vision and skill to deliver both outstanding performance and exceptional value. 

Contact Us

Corporate Office

302 E Jackson Street
Muncie, IN 47305
Phone: 765-213-3400
Fax: 765-286-3479


Branch Offices

117 N. Pendleton Avenue
Pendleton, IN 46064
Phone: 765-778-2525
Fax: 765-778-7636

915 Jackson Street
Anderson, IN 46016
Phone: 765-644-7818
Fax: 765-641-2750

107 S. Main Street
Winchester, IN 47394
Phone: 765-584-1121
Fax: 765-584-1843

207 N. Columbia Street
Union City, IN 47390
Phone: 765-964-3116
Fax: 765-964-3343